Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit February 9, 1954, 14625_1 (Dougherty v. Szivos)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-02-1954
HOLMES, Circuit Judge.
This is an action for malicious prosecution, in which the court below granted appellee’s motion for an involuntary non-suit, and rendered judgment in his favor on the ground that the.evidence was insufficient to warrant submission of the case to the jury. The question before us is whether there was any issue of fact to be submitted to the jury on the question of probable cause.
The evidence disclosed that on the* night of October 13, 1952, the appellant and her husband, the former an employee of the United States in the Canal Zone, left the non-commissioned officers’ club at Albrook Field, Canal Zone, where they had been drinking intoxicating liquor. While her husband was directly in front of their parked car, Mrs. Dough-erty depressed the clutch pedal of the automobile, causing it to move forward and to hit her husband, thereby pinning him to the railing in the parking lot. He was released by two airmen, who shoved the car back and took Mr. and Mrs. Dougherty to the post dispensary. At the dispensary, the appellant acted in an unruly manner, and was asked to be quiet. Her husband was treated for minor scratches and released. On the same night, an investigation of the accident was made by the air-police of Al-brook Field, wherein appellant made a statement to the appellee, a member of said police, that she had run over her husband with their automobile. On the following day, acting with the advice and consent of his superiors, the ap-pellee filed a sworn complaint charging the appellant with operating a motor vehicle while intoxicated in violation of Title 5, Section 512, of the Canal Zone Code. Subsequently, acting under military orders, the appellee dismissed said complaint; and, soon thereafter, the appellant brought this suit against him for malicious prosecution.
The appellant testified at the trial that she did not remember telling the appellee that she had run over her husband.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit