District Court, S.D. California January 20, 1954, Crim. A. No. 23290-CD (United States v. Bougie)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-01-1954

TOLIN, District Judge.

At the close of the prosecution’s evidence, defendant addressed a motion to the Court for entry of judgment of acquittal, as provided in Rule 29, Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, 18 U.S. C.A., on the ground that the evidence is insufficient to sustain a conviction of the offense charged in the indictment.

The body of the indictment reads as follows:

“On or about November 30, 1953, in Los Angeles County, California, within the Central Division of the Southern District of California, defendant Melvin E. Bougie, in a matter within the jurisdiction of a department and agency of the United States, to wit: the United States Post Office, said matter being the application for Christmas Employment with the United States Post Office by said defendant, did knowingly and wilfully falsify, conceal, and cover up a material fact, and did make a false, fictitious and fraudulent statement and representation, as follows on Form C-l, Application for Christmas Employment, in answer to question 14 thereon: ‘Have you ever been arrested for an offense for which you were fined or sentenced?’, said defendant answered on said form, ‘No’.’’

It is noted that the customary allegation that the statement was false in certain particulars has been omitted *360and there is no allegation from which a reader of the indictment can determine wherein the falsity of the alleged statement resides. All that is alleged is that the quoted statement is false but in what particular cannot be determined from the indictment. It is a fundamental rule of pleading falsity that the indictment state the particulars constituting the falsity. The following cases, although not involving misstatements in exactly the way they are allegedly present here, demonstrate the necessity of pleading more than mere conclusion. Facts which lead to the conclusion must be pleaded. United States v. Williams, 5 Cir., 203 F.2d 572; United States v. Schneiderman, D.C., 102 F.Supp. 87; United States v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.