District Court, District of Columbia April 15, 1954, No. 4241-51 (Sun Oil Co. v. Watson)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-04-1954
LETTS, District Judge.
At the trial defendant Esso Standard Oil Company objected to the introduction of the “third party” registrations (plaintiff’s exhibit 3), under the doctrine that prior trademark registrations may not be considered for the purpose of giving a limited application to an opposer’s mark and that such third party registrations may not be considered in determining the question of confusing similarity between the mark of an applicant and that of an opposer. The court recognizes the force of the objection but is of opinion that the objection is not sufficient to rule out the evidence in view of the purpose announced by plaintiff in offering the exhibit. I quote from a transcript of the proceedings, “Mr. Busser: I offer in evidence a file of registered trademarks all having as a part thereof, as a syllable thereof, either as a prefix or suffix, the word VIS, which marks are distinguishable, obviously, one from another only by reason of the dominant syllable associated with the suffix, VIS, which we are all agreed is simply a well-known abbreviation for “viscosity.” Plaintiff’s exhibit *6303 was received for the purpose so announced. It is true that the colloquy which followed plaintiff’s offer of the exhibit related in large part to the applicability of the principles of law embodied in the objection of defendant, Esso Standard Oil Company; but plaintiff made clear the purpose of his offer when near the end of the colloquy he renewed his offer of the exhibit in the following language “Now, this evidence that I propose to submit proves conclusively that the dominant part of this mark, these marks, are respectively UNI and SUN.” The court concludes that plaintiff’s exhibit 3 was properly received for the purpose of such offer. No weight will be given to the exhibit in violation of the principles of law mentioned in the objection interposed by defendant Esso Standard Oil Company.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit