District Court, S.D. New York March 31, 1954 (Skupski v. Western Navigation Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-03-1954

NOONAN, District Judge.

A third party defendant, Maher Stevedoring Corporation, moves to quash the return of service and to vacate the third-party summons and complaint in this action on the ground that it is not subject to service of process within the State of New York.

The moving party is a corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of New Jersey. Its principal office is located in Port Newark, New Jersey. It has no office of its own for the conduct of its business in New York. Nevertheless, certain facts that must be considered include the following:

1. Maher Stevedoring Corporation, the New Jersey corporation, is wholly owned by Michael E. Maher who is also the sole owner of a New York corporation which formerly had the identical name as the New Jersey corporation but whose name was changed to Maher Stevedoring Co., Inc., two months after service in this action.

2. It was the intention of Mr. Maher, sole owner of both corporations that the New York corporation was to “sub-con*310tract” work to be done in New Jersey to the New Jersey corporation.

3. The New Jersey corporation paid <the New York corporation $500 anticipatorily “in connection with solicitation of business in New York.”

4. The contract covering the work involved in this suit was signed by the New Jersey corporation at the New York Port of Embarkation, 58th Street and First Avenue, Brooklyn, New York.

5. The New York corporation maintained an office and telephone listing in 17 Battery Place, New York City, at which place the name Maher Stevedoring Corporation was listed on the building directory and on the door of the office. An arrangement was made in the New York office that important telephone messages should be relayed to Mr. Maher in New Jersey.

6. The New Jersey corporation has worked for the Marine Transport Lines, Funch Edye & Co., the Port of New York Authority, the United States Lines, Lloyd Brasiliero, Luehenbach Steamship Co., Boise-Griffin Steamship Co.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.