Court of Appeals of Texas March 31, 1955, 3266 (Talley v. Nalley)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-03-1955

McDONALD, Chief Justice.

This is a suit growing out of the sale of an automobile. Parties will be referred to as in the trial court. The defendant, Talley Auto Company, sold the plaintiff, J. R. Nalley, a British made MG Roadster car, representing it to be a

1951 model.

Plaintiff Nalley traded in a used car on the MG Roadster as the down payment and signed an installment note for the balance of the price. Thereafter, when the title certificate was issued on the MG Roadster, it was designated as a

1950

model. Plaintiff tried to get defendant auto dealer to take the MG Roadster back, and give him the car he had traded in on it as well as the money he had paid on the MG. Defendant auto dealer refused to do this, whereupon plaintiff filed this suit, alleging the above, together with the fact that defendant auto dealer had fraudulently, wil-fully and maliciously misrepresented the model of the car, and that plaintiff relied on the representation. Plaintiff’s prayer reads as follows:

“Plaintiff demands judgment for rescission, now tendering said automobile to Defendant, and asks judgment for the return of the purchase price paid by him, rescission of the contract, damages, and exemplary damages.”

Defendant auto company, by cross action, sought to recover the balance due on the purchase note.

The evidence reflects that the difference in the ceiling price of a

1950

and

1951

*740

MG Roadster was $325; and further that plaintiff owed defendant $694 balance on the purchase price of the MG Roadster at the time that he stopped making payments on the car and filed this suit.

Trial was to a jury, which found that: 1) the MG Roadster was not a 1951 model; 2) Plaintiff was damaged in the amount of $325 by virtue of the fact that it was not a 1951 model; 3) and that the representation by defendant that the MG Roadster was a 1951 model was fraudulently made; 4) and was made in wilful disregard of the rights of the plaintiff; 5) and that $500 should be allowed as exemplary damages.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.