Supreme Court of Pennsylvania May 23, 1955, Appeal, 134 (DiMenna v. Philadelphia)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-05-1955

combined-opinion

381 Pa. 596 (1955) DiMenna v. Philadelphia, Appellant. Supreme Court of Pennsylvania. Argued April 26, 1955. May 23, 1955. *597 Before STERN, C.J., STEARNE, JONES, BELL, CHIDSEY and ARNOLD, JJ. Levy Anderson, Deputy City Solicitor, with him Raymond Kitty, Assistant City Solicitor, Jerome J. Shestack, First Deputy City Solicitor, and Abraham L. Freedman, City Solicitor, for appellant. George W. Alexander, Jr., with him D.T. Spagnoletti, for appellee. OPINION PER CURIAM, May 23, 1955: In this suit in trespass plaintiff, Diomira DiMenna, sought to recover damages from the City of Philadelphia for injuries resulting from a fall on the south sidewalk of City Hall at a point some 35 feet east of the southern archway, about 15 feet from the building line and 10 feet from the south curb. The jury returned a verdict in her favor in the sum of $3,000. Plaintiff is an elderly lady who had lost the sight of one eye. At the time of the accident she was carrying a hand-bag and a bundle or shopping bag containing two small plants. She walked west from Juniper Street and had just turned to go south across South Penn Square. It was between 9:30 and 10:30 o'clock in the morning of an April day; the weather was a little cloudy and it was somewhat dark. She claimed that where there was a joinder on the sidewalk of two *598 cement blocks, each about 8 feet square, the one to the west was elevated above the adjoining one to the east as much as three inches.[*] The line between the blocks extended from north to south, and she was walking along or parallel with that line on the west or raised portion when she slipped and fell. The testimony was not very clear in respect to the manner in which the accident happened. Plaintiff testified, not that she tripped or stubbed her toe, but that her left foot "slipped"; the court apparently inferred that this was caused by her straddling the line of joinder between the blocks and that her left foot dropped to the depressed block.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.