Court of Appeals of Texas January 12, 1955, 12761 (Shelton v. Belknap)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-01-1955

NORVELL, Justice.

In our original opinion we set forth the conversation of October 1, 1947, between Coyzet Shelton and M. A. Shelton in dialogue form. Complaint is made of this version of the testimony and we therefore substitute the direct questions and answers relative thereto, as they appear in the statement of facts, omitting only the objections of counsel and testimony ruled out by

*175

the trial court. Coyzet Shelton gave two accounts of this conversation and we adopt the one which she says is most favorable to her. The original opinion is accordingly withdrawn and the following adopted by the Court in lieu thereof:

The trial judge held as a matter of law that the evidence was insufficient to show that appellant had contracted a valid common-law marriage with M. A. Shelton, deceased, and accordingly rendered judgment non obstante veredicto in favor of appel-lees, D. R. Belknap and Adelbert Carpenter. Rule 301, Texas Rules of Civil Procedure. The correctness of this holding is the only question of substance presented by this appeal.

M. A. and Coyzet Shelton had been living together for some time prior to October 30, 1950, when M. A. Shelton was killed in a collision between an automobile in which he was riding and a truck owned by Belk-nap and driven by Carpenter. Coyzet Shelton brought this action as the surviving wife of M. A. Shelton under the wrongful death statute. Article 4671 et seq., Vernon’s Ann.Tex.Stats. She also sued for the benefit of Bertha Sauls and Matthew and James Shelton, the mother of M. A. Shelton and his two sons by a divorced wife. The appellees by a sworn plea challenged the right of Coyzet Shelton to maintain the suit, contending that she was never legally married to M. A. Shelton. This issue was severed from the others in the case, Rule 174(b), and tried to a jury which found, that (1) “On or about October 1, 1947, M. A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.