Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York January 5, 1955 (People ex rel. Kessler v. Cotter)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-01-1955

Per Curiam.

In this habeas corpus proceeding, pursuant to article 77 of the Civil Practice Act, the contest was between the father and the mother for the custody of the child. The parties had previously been divorced and the mother had remarried. The order of the Special Term awarded the custody not to either parent but to a third person, an aunt of the child. There is no finding that the mother was an improper and unfit person or that she had abandoned her right to the care and custody of her child. On the other hand, there is no specific finding to that effect in respect to the father. The court did find that in the home of the father the occupants were all male and by reason thereof, the little girl would not receive proper care therein. It appears that after the conclusion of the hearing, the court interviewed the child, the maternal grandmother and the aunt to whom custody was awarded, apparently without the *207knowledge and consent of the parties to the proceeding. It is evident that the court’s decision was based more upon these interviews than upon the evidence taken in court. The discretion of the court in these matters is a judicial discretion “ and its exercise must have sound and substantial basis in the testimony.” (Bunim v. Bunim, 298 N. Y. 391, 393.)

This proceeding involved no one other than the parents of the child. The custody of the child has been taken from both parents without legal basis. " The mother or father has a right to the care and custody of a child, superior to that of all others, unless he or she has abandoned that right or is proved unfit to assume the duties and privileges of parenthood. ’ ’ (People ex rel. Kropp v. Shepsky, 305 N. Y. 465,468.) As between fit and proper parents who have not abandoned the right to custody, “ the courts must make the best available choice.” (People ex rel. Portnoy v. Strasser, 303 N. Y. 539, 542.) There is no evidence here to sustain the order granting custody to a third person.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.