District Court, D. Kansas March 16, 1955, Civ. A. No. T-817 (Gaitskill v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-03-1955

WALLACE, District Judge.

The plaintiff, Dora Gaitskill, a Kansas citizen, brings this action against the United States pursuant to the Tort Claims Act to recover damages for personal injuries she received when she slipped and fell on a snow-covered hospital ramp while visiting her husband who was a patient at the Winters Veterans’ Hospital in Topeka, Kansas. Plaintiff alleges that her injuries were directly caused by the negligence of Government hospital employees in failing to take proper precautionary steps to make the ramp in question safe for walking. By way of defense, the Government denies that it or any of its employees were in anyway guilty of negligence; and, in addition specifically urges: (1) that plaintiff was a bare licensee to whom the Government only owed the duty to refrain from affirmative acts of negligence; and, (2) that, in any event, plaintiff herself was guilty of negligence which contributed to her own injury.

The evidence indicates that on January 24, 1952, the plaintiff went to the VA hospital in question in response to a telegram from the hospital advising plaintiff that her husband, a patient in such hospital, was seriously ill.1 Upon arrival, plaintiff was assigned by an employee of the VA, to Room No. 4 in building T-7 located on hospital premises.2 This assignment to quarters was recorded on a VA form; and, plaintiff was charged 50$ a day for such quarters.3 Building T-7 is a one story barracks type brick building containing a hall which runs the length of the building (east and west) with the rooms adjoining the hall. At the east end of the building a door opens on to an inclined wooden ramp, which ramp leads to the hospital wards and offices. Such ramp is customarily used by occupants of the guest quarters to go to the various wards and offices.4 After plaintiff’s arrival it was her custom to stay at her husband’s bedside during the day and return to her quarters each evening. On the morning of March 3rd, a little after 10 o’clock a.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.