District Court, S.D. New York May 3, 1955 (In re Third Avenue Transit Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-05-1955

DIMOCK, District Judge.

Six unsecured creditors of these debtors dispute the Trustee’s failure to classify their claims as “six-months claims”. Possible preferential treatment of an as yet undetermined extent turns upon such classification. In the Trustee’s proposed plan of reorganization “six-months claims” are described, in Article I, as follows:

“Six-Months Claims: All claims, as defined,1 which are entitled to pri*625ority consisting mainly of claims for current expenses of ordinary operations incurred by the debtors without the extension of long term credit and within six months prior to the appointment of the Trustee in the reorganization proceedings.”

It is agreed by all concerned that the claims referred to are those given priority by the rule first laid down in Fosdick v. Schall, 99 U.S. 235, 25 L.Ed. 339. I must first ascertain what that rule is and then apply it. Its ascertainment is not easy. The researches of counsel supplemented by such research as has been at my command have not resulted in the discovery of any principle which would account for all of the decisions or even enough of the decisions so that one might say that there was a principle behind them.

Long ago the Supreme Court, after an examination of the cases, remarked “It is apparent from an examination of the above cases that the decision in each one depended upon its special facts. This court has uniformly refrained from laying down any rule as absolutely controlling in every case * * Southern R. v. Carnegie Steel Co., 176 U.S. 257, 284-285, 20 S.Ct. 347, 358, 44 L.Ed. 458. An experienced practitioner in the field, as quoted in Fitzgibbon’s “The Present Status of the Six-Months’ Rule,” 34 Col. Law Rev. 230, 238, n. 36, stated the same thing more bluntly.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.