California Court of Appeal September 26, 1956, Civ. 21641 (Brown v. Guy)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-09-1956

*661

ASHBURN, J.

Malpractice action against a doctor of chiropractic. Verdict for defendant. Plaintiff’s motion for new trial was granted upon the ground of insufficiency of the evidence to support the verdict. Defendant appeals.

Upon the consideration of a motion for a new trial the court must make an independent appraisal of the evidence, including all presumptions and reasonable inferences, and must judicially determine whether the judgment effects a miscarriage of justice. In considering such motion the trial court is not bound by a conflict in the evidence but may be governed by any substantial proof that would reasonably warrant a judgment for the moving party even though such evidence consists of nothing more than inferences from established facts. On appeal from the order it will not be reversed unless the reviewing court concludes that as a matter of law there is no substantial evidence to support a contrary judgment.

(Edler

v.

Sepulveda Park Apts.,

141 Cal.App.2d 675, 677 [297 P.2d 508] ;

Estate of Green,

25 Cal.2d 535, 542 [154 P.2d 692];

Hames

v.

Rust,

14 Cal.2d 119, 124 [92 P.2d 1010] ;

Ballard

v.

Pacific Greyhound Lines,

28 Cal.2d 357, 358, 359 [170 P.2d 465].)

The principal factual issue at the trial was whether defendant had injected into plaintiff’s ischemic (blood-starved) right foot a quantity of ozone, and secondly whether that precipitated gangrene which ultimately caused amputation of the leg.

Appellant’s counsel argue that the evidence was legally insufficient to support a verdict for plaintiff because her testimony was inherently improbable. To reach that conclusion it is necessary, however, to show “either a physical impossibility that they [the witness’ statements] are true, or their falsity must be apparent without resorting to inferences or deductions.”

(People

v.

Huston,

21 Cal.2d 690, 693 [134 P.2d 758].

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.