Illinois Supreme Court September 25, 1956, 33951 (Burrows v. Palmer)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-09-1956
Mr. Justice Bristow
delivered the opinion of the court:
Plaintiffs and a counterclaimant appeal directly to this court from a decree of the circuit court of La Salle County dismissing for want of equity plaintiffs’ complaint and defendant Margaret Burrow’s counterclaim wherein it is prayed that the defendant Burton W. Palmer be decreed to hold title to certain real estate in trust and for other relief.
A freehold being directly in issue, the appeal properly comes directly to this court.
The complaint in substance alleges that Mary F. Palmer, mother of the defendant, Burton W. Palmer, and of the counterclaimant Margaret Burrows, during her lifetime conveyed two apartment buildings to the defendant, Burton W. Palmer, without consideration and for her use and benefit; that a confidential and fiduciary relationship then existed between Mary F. Palmer and her son, Burton W. Palmer; that Burton W. Palmer never reconveyed the title to the buildings to Mary F. Palmer during her lifetime and held the title thereto in trust for her at her death. The suit was instituted by the eight minor children of Margaret Burrows, defendant-counterclaimant, as contingent remaindermen under a testamentary trust created by the last will of Mary F. Palmer, their grandmother. That they were proper parties plaintiffs and have a right to maintain this suit was decided by this court in Burrows v. Palmer, 5 Ill.2d 434, on appeal from an earlier order dismissing their complaint for want of proper parties.
The answer of defendant Burton W. Palmer denied the material allegations of the complaint, alleged his purchase of the properties for a valuable consideration, and also pleaded laches and the statute of limitations as special defenses.
Witnesses called for the plaintiffs were their mother, Margaret Burrows; Dr. Samuel J. Burrows, their father and next friend who instituted the suit; Helen Palmer, wife of the defendant Burton W.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit