Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit April 12, 1956, 12935_1 (Wilbert G. Evans v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-04-1956

BASTIAN, Circuit Judge.

Defendant was charged in a two-count, indictment with grand larceny, D.C. Code, § 22-2201, 1951 Ed., Supp. III, and. with unauthorized use of a vehicle, D.C. Code, § 22-2204, 1951 Ed., both growing-out of the same act. He was convicted on both counts. The trial court sentenced him to imprisonment from two-to five years on the unauthorized use count, and from two to seven years on. the grand larceny count, directing that these sentences run concurrently. Defendant appeals, urging, among other things, that it was error to submit both counts to the jury as they grew out of' the same set of facts and circumstanc.es, and that the offense'of unauthorized uséis included in that of grand larceny. We find no error on this point.

The same act may at times, constitute two offenses and justify findings of guilty on two counts, and separate sentences thereon may be imposed, providing they run concurrently. The-penalty provided by the Code covering-the offense of grand larceny is from one to ten years; the penalty for unauthorized use is a fine or imprisonment not. exceeding five,years, or both. The sentence under the grand larceny count was-no greater than the court had the right to impose. A different result would probably be necessary if the sentences-had been imposed to run consecutively. On the propriety of convictions under both counts of an indictment chargingincludable offenses where the sentences-are made to run concurrently, see Ekberg v. United States, 1 Cir., 1926, 167 F.2d 380.

*381

Defendant complains of the refusal of the trial court to declare a mistrial because of argument of government counsel with reference to the question of the legality of repossession of automobiles.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.