Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit May 2, 1956, 11536 (Jeanette Albin, a Minor, by Ethel v. Pierce, Her Guardian and Next Friend v. T. F. Barrett Construction Company, a Corporation)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-05-1956

SCHNACKENBERG, Circuit Judge.

Plaintiff brought an action to recover damages occasioned by the alleged negligence of defendant in constructing and maintaining a temporary store front or barricade, which, on February 28, 1951, fell upon and injured plaintiff, a pedestrian on a street sidewalk. The jury rendered a verdict for plaintiff, upon which the court entered the judgment from which this appeal is taken. At the close of plaintiff’s evidence and again at the close of all the evidence, defendant filed a motion for a directed verdict on the ground that the evidence was insufficient to establish negligence on the part of defendant. After verdict was returned for plaintiff, defendant filed a motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, reasserting the same ground. The motions were overruled.

Both parties agree that the doctrine of res

ipsa loquitur

applies to this case. However, a man who supervised the construction for the defendant testified as a witness for plaintiff, and later as defendant’s witness, and explained the construction of the barricade. Defendant contends that “since a full explanation was made by the defendant regarding the construction of the barricade, then the plaintiff lost the benefit of the doctrine of

res ipsa loquitur,

and it was incumbent on her to prove seme act of negligence”. Defendant fj^Mter contends that, “since no act of ^(gligence was proved by plaintiff”, the evidence was not sufficient to sustain the verdict, and it was error to overrule defendant’s motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict.

Defendant was doing some construction work at the front of a building occupied by a drugstore. In this connection defendant had constructed and was maintaining a barricade parallel to and along a public sidewalk in Gary, Indiana.

Eugene A. Barrett testified as a witness for plaintiff and later as a witness for defendant.

Relevant facts to which he testified are: The barricade was 10 to 12 feet high and 16 feet long.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.