Texas Supreme Court March 14, 1956, A-5363 (Whitener v. Traders and General Ins. Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-03-1956
Mr. Justice Culver
delivered the opinion of the Court.
Petitioner, Whitener, sued to set aside an award of the Industrial Accident Board. Judgment in his favor was reversed and remanded by the Court of Civil Appeals for the reason that improper jury argument by petitioner’s counsel was calculated to and probably did cause the rendition of an erroneous judgment, 279 S.W. 2d 152.
We are of the opinion, however, that although some, if not all, of the argument was improper, yet taken separately or as a whole the argument cannot be said to have probably influenced the jury to the prejudice of the respondent under circumstances of this case.
That portion of the argument which the Court of Civil Appeals considered the most harmful arose from counsel’s efforts to belittle medical testimony offered by respondent in connection with a prior back ailment of petitioner. The statement is as follows:
“ ‘One of the doctors got on the stand and said it was evolu-tional melancolía. “What is that, doctor?” “Oh, that is the middle age, that is the change of life. Like a woman, the middle age change of life.” Another doctor, “What is his trouble, Dr. Wilcox?” “Old age, it is old age.” I was expecting that maybe Dr. Wolfe would come in here and say in this case of Mr. Whitener’s maybe he ought to have his unnecessary female organs removed, and let us hear it. Talk about inconsistencies.’ ”
Respondent contends that the effect of this argument was to comment upon the fact that Dr. Wolfe was not called as a witness and would have testified differently from other witnesses for respondent. We do not so interpret the argument. Dr. Wolfe was a physician of petitioner’s own choice. It seems that if any inference was to be drawn it was rather that petitioner’s own doctor would have agreed that petitioner’s condition was due solely to old age rather than to an injury. At worst the remarks were inappropriate and a misplaced attempt at humor.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit