District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania January 11, 1956, Civ. A. No. 12258 (Crutcher v. Curtis Publishing Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-01-1956

GRIM, District Judge.

On the basis of an idea supplied in 1934 by Lawrence S. Leopold, the plaintiff, Carlile Crutcher, developed a cartoon strip bearing the name, “You Be The Judge.” The name and strip were first used in commerce July 6, 1936. The plaintiff applied to the Patent Office for registration of the name on October 1, 1936, Serial No. 383,836, for “cartoons published in installments at periodical intervals” in Class 38, Prints and Publications, and the name was registered April 13, 1937, No. 344,996, under the Act of February 20, 1905, c. 592, 15 U.S.C. See. 81 et seq.1

The name was used as the title of a series of groups of cartoons. Each group was made up of a total of six horizontal strips of four consecutive drawings dealing with one subject in such a way that a publication could print all 24 drawings in one issue or one strip of four cartoons in six successive issues. The series was so arranged that it could be conveniently used for daily or Sunday publication in newspapers. The subject matter of each group of 24 was an historical event, usually a court trial, stating a problem and asking the reader to compare his opinion with the court’s decision. This type of material is termed in the periodical publishing business a “feature” and is considered useful in attracting new readers and thus increasing circulation.

Between 1936 and 1942 the “feature” was purchased at various times by 71 newspapers in the United States and 21 newspapers in foreign countries. Forty domestic subscribers purchased the service in 1936, 57 in 1937, 60 in 1938, 51 in 1939, 46 in 1940, 32 in 1941, and 15 in 1942. Plaintiff entered the United States Army Air Force in May of 1942 and thereafter found it impossible to manage the sale and distribution of the “feature.” The last publication date for which the “feature” was furnished to domestic subscribers was September 4, 1942, and at that time the subscribers numbered five.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.