District Court, E.D. Virginia April 13, 1956, No. 1880 (Biscow v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-04-1956

HOFFMAN, District Judge.

This is an action instituted by plaintiffs to recover income taxes paid for the calendar year 1949 pursuant to a deficiency assessment and a subsequent denial of a claim for refund. The plaintiff, Peggy Biscow, is a party by reason of having filed a joint return with her husband, Isadore Biscow. The controversy arises from the disallowance, as a deductible loss, of the undepreciated cost of a certain building acquired in *7761945 by a partnership composed of Isadore Biscow and James Fox, the building thereon having been demolished in 1949 to provide parking space for a modern restaurant erected by the partnership.

Under a special inquiry submitted to the jury it was determined that, at the time of purchase in 1945, the partnership had no then intention of demolishing the buildings and improvements thereon for the purpose of erecting another building in its place. The verdict of the jury is amply supported by the evidence and its finding is approved.

Submitted by agreement to the Court is the issue of the effect, if any, of an after-acquired intention (not existing at the time of purchase) to demolish, coupled with the erection of the restaurant building at approximately the same time, with the partnership claiming a demolition loss during the year of removal.

The partnership acquired by purchase, in 1945, lots 1, 2 and the southern % of 3, in block 69, plat 3, of the property of the Virginia Beach Development Company for the sum of $41,500. The land is located on the ocean front a total frontage of 125 feet and running back a distance of 150 feet to the main street in the City of Virginia Beach. Situated on lot 1 at the southern or 28th Street corner of the property was a frame building used, at the time of sale, as a rooming house.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.