District Court, W.D. Kentucky June 1, 1956, Civ. No. 2806 (Sparks v. Western Union Telegraph Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-06-1956

BROOKS, District Judge.

This action is submitted on the motion of the defendant, Western Union Telegraph Company, to set aside a jury verdict for the plaintiff, Mary Ruth Sparks, and to enter judgment in accordance with defendant’s motion for a directed verdict.

The facts surrounding the accident in which the plaintiff was injured are not disputed. The plaintiff was crossing Market Street at the intersection of Fourth and Market Streets in Louisville, Kentucky, in a designated crosswalk when she stepped on a manhole cover maintained by the defendant. The manhole cover which was located approximately in the middle of the crosswalk was 27 inches in diameter and there were four holes of one inch in diameter in its cover. Plaintiff’s heel, which was approximately % of an inch in diameter, went into one of these holes causing her to fall, resulting in the injuries for which she obtained her verdict.

The defendant introduced evidence to show that there are over 5,523 manhole covers maintained in the City of Louisville and that there are many catch basins, cellar doors and coal holes with openings as large or larger than the one inch holes in the Western Union manhole cover in question. It was argued that a reasonable man would not have anticipated the danger inherent in manhole covers with holes in them, since manhole covers are in such common use that a person is held to know and appreciate their potential danger and that no property owner should be held to anticipate *330that any injury will ever occur by reason of the existence of such a commonplace condition.

Strong reliance is placed upon what the defendant designates as the “common use” doctrine as applied in the case of Greater Louisville First Federal Savings & Loan Association v. Stone, Ky.1951, 242 S.W.2d 739, 741. In this case a child 15 months old was burned by a hot exposed radiator pipe in a building into which he had accompanied his mother.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.