District Court, E.D. New York June 28, 1956, No. 19727 (Bleakley Transportation Co. v. M. F. Hickey Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-06-1956
GALSTON, District Judge.
The libel alleges that on September 15, 1950 the libellant’s scow, Harvard, loaded with sand and gravel consigned to the respondent, was placed at the dock of the respondent and was seriously damaged by grounding on a hard, uneven bottom, which caused a twisting and straining of the scow. The fault charged is that the respondent failed to maintain berths and approaches to the dock in a safe condition for scows carrying cargoes to the respondent.
The answer of the respondent denies essential allegations of the complaint, and alleges that the tug Frank Buchanan picked up the scow Harvard and placed the scow in tow; also that the scow was loaded with a mixed cargo of sand and gravel weighing between nine hundred and fifty, and a thousand tons. From the Gallagher Brothers Whitestone Stake-boat, together with another loaded scow, the tow proceeded to respondent’s plant located on the north bank of Flushing Creek, just west of the Whitestone Parkway. The respondent alleges that either at respondent’s plant or adjacent thereto, the tug Frank Buchanan picked up a scow, Sands Point, which lay outside of another scow, the Marion, and that the Marion was alongside respondent’s bulkhead. It is further alleged that the Frank Buchanan left the scow Harvard drifting in the stream, and that it proceeded upstream with the scows Jacob Cox and Sands Point. Thereafter, at a different stage of the tide, the Frank Buchanan returned to the waters adjacent to the respondent’s plant and attempted to land the Harvard outside of another scow. Then the Frank Buchanan departed, leaving the Harvard stranded. , The respondent’s answer also makes allegation of the arrival on the following day, September 16, 1950, of the tug New Rochelle at a location where the libellant’s scow was aground, and succeeded in pushing the Harvard up alongside the scow Marion.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit