District Court, D. Minnesota September 1, 1956, Civ. No. 2880 (Braniff Airways, Inc. v. Falkingham)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-09-1956

DONOVAN, District Judge.

Summary judgment is moved for by the defendant Commission. The motion is directed at the complaint.1 No answer has been made. No supporting affidavits are filed.

Urging lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter of the action and failure of the complaint to state a claim, movant argues that the motion for judgment is based not so much on the immunity of the State from suit, in the strict sense, but rather upon the claim of “the well-established rule in Minnesota that a public corporation, at all levels of government, has immunity from liability for negligence in the discharge of governmental functions.”2

Opposing the motion, plaintiff emphasizes that the declaratory purposes of movant’s act of genesis describing them to be “public and governmental” are conditioned upon and subject to the explicit authority to “sue and be sued” as endowed by the Minnesota legislature in the same Act.3

The instant case, admittedly, has to do with the construction and interpretation of 22 Minnesota Statutes Annotated, Sections 360.101, 360.106, 360.107, Subdivision 4, and 360.113.

Plaintiff relies to a large extent on Acts of Congress, interpreted as giving governmental agencies “many of the characteristics of private business corporations, distinguishing them from the government itself”.4

As stated by the Minnesota court in the Casper case (searching for a solution of the problem here posed), it is a question of legislative “intent”,-or, as agreed to in different words by the United States Supreme Court in the Keifer case [306 U.S. 381, 59 S.Ct. 518], the legis*937lative branch of government “may, of course, endow a governmental corporation - with the government’s immunity. But always the question is: has it done so?”

If the Acts here in dispute had been interpreted by the Minnesota Supreme Court to mean what movant is here contending, there would be no problem. But in my opinion it has not.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.