Supreme Court of Oklahoma April 23, 1957, No. 37463 (National Casualty Co. v. First National Bank & Trust Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-04-1957

BLACKBIRD, Justice.

Defendant in error, executor of the estate of a deceased Tulsa dentist, Dr. L. C. Trotter, instituted this action against plaintiff in error, to recover a certain sum of money as monthly benefits for the period of said dentist’s disability before his death, allegedly due under the terms of & group insurance contract plaintiff in error entered into with said dentist, as a member of the American Dental Association. At the close of the evidence, the trial court sustained the executor’s motion for a directed verdict in the sum of $1,773.34; and, after entry of judgment in accord with such verdict, the defendant insurance company perfected the present appeal. Our continued reference to the parties will be by their trial court designations.

The .substance of the alleged defense to the action was that defendant’s issuance of the insurance contract, or policy, was procured by fraud, which consisted of misrepresentations Dr. Trotter allegedly made concerning his health and medical history in applying for the policy, which misrepresentations were allegedly relied upon by defendant in issuing the policy.

Dr. Trotter’s application for the policy was dated April 1, 1954. The policy was thereafter issued, and became effective one month later. Trotter, hereinafter referred to as the testate, became disabled June 23, 1954, by reason of the illness from which he never recovered.

In the present appeal, there is no dispute about the amount of plaintiff’s recovery, there being no contention that if defendant was liable on the contract at all, the verdict is excessive. As above indicated, however, it is earnestly contended that, on the basis of the evidence, the insurance contract was vitiated and rendered unenforceable by the testate’s fraudulent misrepresentations of the condition of his health and medical history on his application for the contract, or policy.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.