New York Supreme Court March 11, 1957 (Bodner v. 601 W. 26 Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-03-1957

Matthew M. Levy, J.

The accident occurred August 8, 1951. The bill of particulars was dated January 23, 1953. In February 1954, the plaintiffs served notice that at the time of the trial they intend to move to amend certain paragraphs of the bill so as to claim constructive notice on the part of defendant 601 W, 26 Corp. In October 1956, the plaintiffs served notice that upon the trial they will move to amend and supplement their bill by a statement as to the aggravated condition of certain injuries, and offered to submit the physically hurt plaintiff to a further physical examination before trial. Also in October 1956, the plaintiffs served notice that upon the trial they would move to amend their complaint by increasing the ad dammi-m sought by the female plaintiff from $75,000 to *833$125,000 and that of her husband from $10,000 to $25,000. In November 1956, one of the defendants conducted the physical examination afforded it by plaintiffs’ offer, and examined the X-ray photographs as to the claimed condition.

Instead of awaiting the trial, the plaintiffs moved before me at Special Term (on an affidavit only of trial counsel, who quotes from the doctor’s recent findings), for leave to serve an amended and supplemental bill of particulars as to notice and injuries, and for leave to amend their complaint as to damages. No objection is made by the defendants to the proposed amendment as to notice, and it is granted. Objection is made to the proposed amendments as to injuries and damages, the defendants claiming that, in the absence of supporting affidavits by the injured plaintiff, by her attorney and by a physician, the motion papers are defective and furnish no justifiable basis for the amendments sought.

While there have been some rulings to the effect that trial counsel has no implied authority to make some applications to the court when grounded solely on his own affidavit, I do not think that that objection is tenable in respect of the present motion.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.