New York Supreme Court July 10, 1957 (North American Holding Corp. v. Murdock)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-07-1957
John L. Flynn, J.
This is a certiorari proceeding which brings up for review a determination made by respondents, Harris H. Murdock, et al., constituting the Board of Standards and Appeals. The board denied an application by the petitioner under section 21 of the Zoning Resolution, for a variance permitting petitioner to make a limited business use of five stores already in existence on the side street of petitioner’s property comprising the southeast corner of East 167th Street and Grand Concourse in the Borough of The Bronx. The land is an irregular plot with a frontage of 204.84 feet on Grand Concourse and 96.86 feet on East 167th Street. The land is improved with a six-story apartment house erected in 1938, known as 1182-1186 Grand Concourse and 180-188 East 167th Street. The store space is in the cellar portion of this building, not on any part of the Grand Concourse, but entirely on East 167th Street, beginning at a point 25 feet east of the Concourse.
The site involved in this proceeding and 167th Street are in residence and business use, C area, Class 1 height districts; Grand Concourse is in a residence use, C area, Class 1 height district. Actually a small portion of petitioner’s property is in a business use district.
The original building plans, filed on June 30, 1936, provided for the erection of a six-story multiple dwelling with stores on the 167th Street frontage, in that portion of the cellar beginning at a point 25 feet from the Concourse. The plans were rejected by the commissioner of housing and buildings on June 30, 1936 on the grounds that the stores shown in the plans would be located in a residence use district. The property owner appealed to the Board of Standards and Appeals. The board first denied the application on October 20, 1936, by a tie vote, 2 affirmative and 2 negative.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit