District Court, E.D. New York February 5, 1957, Civ. No. 13406 (Puterman v. Pennsylvania Railroad)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-02-1957

RAYFIEL, District Judge.

This is an action to recover damages for personal injuries sustained by the plaintiff while a passenger on one of the defendant’s trains, which allegedly came to a sudden stop while approaching or entering the Pennsylvania Station in New York City.

Paragraph “Tenth” of the complaint alleges that the plaintiff’s injuries resulted from various acts of negligence on the part of the defendant, including, inter alia, the failure “to have proper brakes and braking mechanisms on the train and locomotive.”

The plaintiff now moves under Rule 15 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, 28 U.S.C. for leave to amend the complaint by adding to paragraph “Tenth” thereof an allegation to the- effect that the defendant violated the provisions of the Safety Appliance Act, Title 45 U.S. Code, §§ 1-16, in that thetra-iii on which; the plaintiff was a passenger was caused, to come to a sudden and-violent stop be-, cause it was equipped with defective air, brake appliances.

The defendant opposes the' application, on the ground (1) that the --Safety Appliance Act does not grant a right of ae-tion thereunder to a ■ passenger; (2) that, assuming that it does grant such a right, the proposed amendment would constitute a new cause of action, and, hence, be barred by the applicable Statute of-Limitations of the State of New York, Section 49 of the New York Civil Practice Act, because more - than three years have- elapsed since the cause of action herein accrued; and (3) that.the proposed amendment is not, as contended by the- plaintiff, a repetition in, substance of her claim, stated in paragraph “Tenth” of the complaint, that the defendant ■ failed to equip the train in question with .proper brakes, but sets up a different theory of liability which, at the current stage of this . litigation, would seriously prejudice its rights.- The grounds urged will-be considered in that order.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.