District Court, M.D. North Carolina May 17, 1957, Civ. No. 1078 (Iowa National Mutual Insurance Co. v. Davis)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-05-1957

HAYES, District Judge.

The plaintiff here seeks a declaratory judgment to the effect that it is not liable to any of the defendants ón a policy of liability insurance issued by it to Margaret Inez Davis on a 1956 Oldsmobile. This car was involved in a three car collision on August 6, 1956, while being operated by Boyd Pierce, son-in-law of Mrs. Davis, and each of the defendants is financially interested in the subject matter, and a genuine controversy exists. Jurisdiction is conceded.

Mrs. Davis was unable to obtain any insurance and was required to apply for a policy under the “Assignment Risk” plan prevailing under the law of North Carolina. Each Company doing business in this state is required to write its pro rata portion of such risks. An insured is not entitled to have such a policy nor is a Company authorized to write it under this plan until the applicant has tried and failed to get insurance otherwise. When such a risk is assumed, the Company is compelled to renew it for an additional year except for causes immaterial here.

The original policy was issued to the named insured, Margaret Inez Davis, under that plan, on one 1953 Oldsmobile and one 1952 Oldsmobile which was driven exclusively, according to the application, by her daughter Norma Jean, who was 17 years old who resided in the home and attended school. This policy was written in 1955 and renewed in May 1956.

The parents decided to make her a gift of a new car for a present on account of her graduation and wedding, occurring about June 1, 1956.

The new Oldsmobile was purchased by turning the 1952 Oldsmobile which had been purchased by Mr. Davis and put in the name of Mrs. Davis and by Mr. Davis . paying the difference in cash.

The invoice to the new car was made to Norma Jean Davis, the title was put in her name and she took out in her name theft and collision insurance in another Company.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.