District Court, S.D. Iowa March 22, 1957, No. 3-732 (Mitchell v. American Republic Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-03-1957
REEVES, District Judge.
By this action the plaintiff seeks to enjoin the defendant from claimed violations of the Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C.A. § 201 et seq. There is no controversy as to the facts.
From January 1, 1955, until July 23, 1956, the defendant arranged with a large number of individuals to do home work for the defendant in addressing mail matter to sundry individuals who might be interested as prospects for insurance. From the period July 23, 1956 until the present time it arranged with a lesser number, namely, eighteen individuals, to do identical work. The defendant’s arrangement with the individuals of each group was by contract which contained a recital on the part of the individuals that:
“I hereby offer and agree, at my own risk and cost, as an independent contractor and according to methods adopted or to be adopted by me, to act as a home addresser for said *530American Republic Insurance Company, herein referred to as Company.”
Then this significant recital:
“I undertake to address such cards, letters or other communications as said Company may require to be addressed, subject to the instructions attached hereto. * * *(Emphasis mine.)
In other portions of the contract exceptions were made regarding the will of the worker:
“ * * * as otherwise provided in the instructions hereto attached * * * »
The discretion of the individual was limited by the instructions attached to the contract. The provisions of the contract varied somewhat on compensation, but such compensation was based upon each 1,000 completed items.
It was admitted that the advertising matter was used in interstate commerce, and that therefore the individuals were producing or preparing matter to be used in interstate commerce.
By reason of the contract labeling each individual as an “independent contractor,” it is the contention of the defendant that such work did not fall within the Fair Labor Standards Act.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit