District Court, W.D. Pennsylvania September 24, 1957, Civ. A. No. 14674 (Schrag v. Koontz)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-09-1957
MARSH, District Judge.
At the request of the Aetna Casualty and Surety Company, William J. Lancaster, Esq., a member of the bar of this Court, entered his appearance for Leah Griffith Schrag, Administratrix of the Estate of David Schrag, deceased, the third-party defendant in the above entitled case. After filing an answer for her, and after the expiration of about nine months, the said attorney asked leave to withdraw his appearance, alleging that his client, the said insurance company, “now believes that it does not owe coverage, and that it does not owe a defense to the claim of Leah Griffith Schrag, in her own right, against Leah Griffith Schrag, Administratrix of the Estate of David Schrag, deceased, third-party defendant.”1 Accordingly, the insurance company ordered Attorney Lancaster to withdraw his appearance for the third-party defendant. Under Rule 2 of this court, counsel must obtain leave of court to withdraw an appearance.
The petition is formally resisted by the plaintiffs. They argue that the said insurance company not only legally owes a defense and coverage to the third-party defendant, but also the said company and its counsel by actively assuming “control of the third-party defendant’s case, have waived their right to deny coverage, and are estopped from asserting this argument.”2
The court is of the opinion that said attorney should be permitted to withdraw his appearance, unless it can be shown that the third-party defendant would be prejudiced by this action.
The Administratrix has not specified how she will be prejudiced by the withdrawal of insurer’s counsel, and the court is unable to perceive any legal disadvantage which might result therefrom. To be sure, plaintiffs’ counsel argues that the Administratrix will be prejudiced for “practical” reasons, but these reasons do not appear in his brief.
The Administratrix, as a plaintiff, has retained competent and skillful counsel.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit