District Court, E.D. New York November 29, 1957, Civ. A. 14874, 17385 (Whitfield & Sheshunoff, Inc. v. Fairchild Engine & Airplane Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-11-1957

REEVES, District Judge.

While the pleadings and testimony in the above cases are extensive, yet the issue is simple and easily stated. The question involved is the right to use a patented process or processes in causing aluminum to adhere to steel or other metals. Both parties have rights as licensees, but in different fields. Fixing the boundaries of these fields constitutes the issue and judicial problem. The process or processes had been designated by the parties with the agreed name of “Al-Fin.”

The plaintiff, Whitfield & Sheshunoff, Inc., in No. 14,874, filed its action in October, 1954. It complained in equity and sought an injunction against the defendant to restrain it from holding out to the public and negotiating licenses in its claimed field, which was, by agreement, in the field of strip, sheet and wire, but asserted by plaintiff to extend to the applications of said processes before, as well as after, fabrication.

Plaintiff further sought to have an adjudication “that the exclusive rights of *465the plaintiff attach to all articles made of sheet, strip or wire, whether such ‘Al-Fin’ processes be applied before or after fabrication.”

There was a further prayer for an accounting for such use as the defendant might have made of the said “Al-Fin” processes in the field of sheet, strip and wire, “whether such processes be applied before or after fabrication,” and that the defendant pay over to the plaintiff the amount found to be due upon such accounting.

To this action the defendant interposed a denial in part, particularly as to its alleged misuse or infringement upon plaintiff’s license. It averred an estoppel and also set forth a counterclaim based upon the alleged misuse by plaintiff of what it treated as a very limited license in the use of the so-called “Al-Fin” process.

Subsequently, and as a procedural maneuver, the defendant filed its action, numbered 17,385, wherein it charged that Whitfield & Sheshunoff, Inc., and one Marshall G.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.