District Court, S.D. New York November 26, 1957 (American Visuals Corp. v. Holland)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-11-1957
THOMAS F. MURPHY, District Judge.
This action is for infringement of copyright, unfair competition and the misuse of confidential information by plaintiff’s former employees. It relates to two pamphlets — plaintiff’s pamphlet entitled “Killer in the Streets” and defendant Holland’s “It Can’t Happen to Us.” Each pamphlet details pictorially in cartoon style three common types of highway accidents resulting from careless driving by members of one family.
Plaintiff originally moved before Judge Dawson for preliminary injunction, which was denied with opinion. D.C.S.D.N.Y.1954, 126 F.Supp. 513, 514. On appeal Judge Dawson’s order was affirmed. 2 Cir., 1955, 219 F.2d 223.
Judge Dawson compared both pamphlets and found “An examination of these two books or pamphlets does not sufficiently indicate that the execution of the basic idea in the first book has been plagiarized in the other. * * * The fact that certain episodes are used which are typical of the dangers of careless or reckless driving is not, in and of itself, sufficient to indicate in a motion for preliminary injunction that the book in question was an infringement of the copyrighted book.” He concluded on the infringement issue, “the treatment of the episodes in the second book is different. The art work is different. The composition is different. It thus does not appear that there is sufficient similarity in the execution of the work to justify the Court in reaching the conclusion on this motion for a preliminary injunction that the registered copyright has been infringed.” On the other causes of action he found that there were sufficient issues of fact to warrant a trial.'
On appeal, the Court of Appeals held that there was no abuse of discretion in denying injunction pendente lite. It went on to state, “Only the expression of ideas is copyrightable, and Judge Dawson was of opinion (126 F.Supp. 515) [sic] that there was not ‘sufficient similarity in the execution of the work’ to show infringement.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit