Oregon Supreme Court February 28, 1958 (Moore v. FRITSCHE)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-02-1958

PERRY C. J.

This suit was brought by the plaintiff Abbie Elizabeth Moore against the defendant Walter Kropp, administrator eta of the estate of Otto Snyder, deceased, and against the defendants Frank Koshmiter, Anna Fritsche, Else Rochlich, Rosmare Rochlich, Lorn

*105

Eochlich, Klaus Eochlich, Jochen Eochlich, Minna Perscheid, and Giese Gunstman, legatees under the last will and testament of Otto Snyder, deceased, for a decree establishing a contract between plaintiff and said Otto Snyder, and ordering that the contract be specifically performed; and for a further decree restraining said Walter Kropp from making distribution of the estate pursuant to the terms of the will of Otto Snyder, deceased, and quieting plaintiff’s title and right to distribution against the claims of the defendant legatees. From a decree in favor of the plaintiff the defendants Anna Fritsche, Else Eochlich, Eosmare Eochlich, Lorn Eochlich, Klaus Eochlich, Jochen Eochlich, Minna Perscheid, and Giese Gunstman have appealed.

Plaintiff’s claim is based upon an oral contract to make a will in favor of plaintiff in consideration of services rendered to the promisor, Otto Snyder, during his lifetime. It happens that in most cases which treat contracts of this type, and the present case is no exception, the promisor is dead and has died either making no will at all or making an invalid will under the statute of wills. In this state, however, such contracts have been held lawful, and specific performance of them has, under proper circumstances, been granted. When the existence thereof and breach by the promisor are properly established in evidence, and no adequate remedy is available at law, courts of equity will grant relief.

Tiggelbeck v. Russell, et al.,

187 Or 554, 213 P2d 156;

Magness v. Magness,

148 Or 44, 33 P2d 1005, and cases cited therein.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.