Supreme Court of Connecticut July 8, 1958 (Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. v. Murray)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-07-1958

Daly, C. J.

The plaintiff, an insurance company, brought this action for a declaratory judgment determining whether the liability, if any, of Homer V. Murray, who caused injuries and damage to certain

*429

of the defendants, is covered by the terms of a policy held by him and issued by the plaintiff. The defendants have appealed from a judgment determining that Ms acts did not give rise to accidental injuries and damage and that the policy, wMch only covers liability arising from an accident or from injuries accidentally sustained, does not cover Ms liability for the injuries and damage claimed, because they were caused by Ms intentional acts.

The defendants have assigned error in the refusal of the court to add twenty-four paragraphs of their draft finding, contending that these paragraphs contained facts which were admitted or undisputed. Many of the suggested facts are not admitted or undisputed. That a witness testified to a fact without direct contradiction is not of itself sufficient; the trial court must be the judge of the credit to be given to a witness. Practice Book § 397. Certain facts sought to be added are already in the finding. As some of the proposed paragraphs consist of immaterial or evidential matters, the facts contained in them cannot be added.

Starkel

v.

Edward Balf Co.,

142 Conn. 336, 337, 114 A.2d 199. Other additions sought would not directly affect the ultimate facts upon wMch the judgment depends. No useful purpose would, therefore, be served by adding these additional facts to the finding.

Cole

v.

Associated Construction Co.,

141 Conn. 49, 51, 103 A.2d 529.

The court found the following unchallenged facts: Prior to August 26, 1955, the plaintiff had issued an automobile liability and physical damage policy to Homer V. Murray, hereinafter referred to as the insured, and on that date the policy was in full force and effect.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.