Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit May 21, 1958, 15885 (Realty Investment Company, Inc., a Corporation v. Armco Steel Corporation, a Corporation)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-05-1958

VOGEL, Circuit Judge.

Appellant, a Missouri corporation, brought this suit against the appellee, an Ohio corporation, for a real estate broker’s commission, appellant claiming that appellee employed it in the matter of procuring for appellee certain property owned by the Ford Motor Company. Suit was commenced in Missouri state court but removed to the federal court on the ground of diversity of citizenship and involvement of more than the statutory amount.

Prior to trial, appellee moved for summary judgment, basing such motion upon admitted exhibits, depositions and affidavits hereinafter referred to. Appellee contended in the motion that the pleadings, exhibits, etc., established (1) that “plaintiff was not the procuring cause of the purchase of the Ford Assembly Plant by defendant”; (2) “plaintiff was not employed by defendant to procure the purchase of the Ford Assembly Plant for defendant”; and (3) “plaintiff attempted to act on behalf of both buyer and seller without full disclosure to both parties”. The trial court, in a memorandum and order sustaining appellee's motion for summary judgment, determined under item 2 that the plaintiff was not employed by defendant to procure the property, that “the undisputed facts before the court, as revealed by the deposition of Jack Seligson, plaintiff’s agent, and the exhibits identified by him and attached to his deposition, is dispositive of the issue of employment, which after all, is the first question to be determined.” The trial court then found:

“From a careful study of Selig-son’s testimony and the written communications attached to the deposition, I am unable to find anything that would suggest any contract of employment, expressed or implied.

“It Is Therefore, my conclusion that there is no genuine issue of any material fact, and that the Motion for Summary Judgment should be, and is hereby sustained.”

Under the provisions of Rule 56 (c), Fed. Rules Civ. Proc., 28 U.S.C.A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.