United States Court of Military Appeals July 3, 1958, No. 10,986 (United States v. Silva)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-07-1958
*422Opinion of the Court
George W. Latxmek, Judge:
The accused was convicted of violations of Article 92, Uniform Code of Military Justice, 10 USC § 892, stemming from his alleged black-market activities while serving as an airman in England. Intermediate appellate authorities, while modifying his sentence, affirmed the court-martial’s findings of guilty. We granted review to consider:
(1) Whether the evidence is sufficient to support the findings of violation of a United States Air Force Europe regulation (specification 1).
(2) Whether the law officer correctly instructed on constructive knowledge of said regulation.
The accused was charged in specification 1 with violating paragraph 15, USAFE Regulation 176-5, September 20, 1955:
“ ... by wrongfully selling an Omega Constellation Chronometer watch, serial # 14123770, purchased from the Air Forces Europe Exchange, to an unknown British Civilian, not an authorized Air Forces Europe Exchange patron.”
In order to sustain the accused’s conviction, the defense argues that the Government was required to show by competent and sufficient evidence that (1) an Omega watch (Serial Number 14123770) was purchased from an Air Force exchange (AFEX) by the accused; (2) that the watch was sold by him; and (3) to a person not an authorized Air Force Europe exchange patron.
As to the three ingredients enumerated above, the Government did not fail to meet its burden as the record contains competent and sufficient evidence to sustain the court-martial’s findings on each element. A clerk at the AFEX, RAF Station, Manston, England, testified that she sold an Omega watch Number 14123770 to a customer who signed as “A/2d E. Rebart” or “E. Rebat” on February 4, 1956. A copy of the sales receipt and the log book of sales kept in the usual course of business was introduced in evidence and it indicated the date of sale, make, case number, and price of the watch and the customer’s signature.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit