District Court, D. Delaware March 10, 1958, Civ. A. No. 1692 (Central Manufacturing Co. v. B-M-K Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-03-1958

RODNEY, District Judge.

This matter originally concerned an action of declaratory judgment concerning the validity of a patent. The patent was held invalid. An appeal has been noticed and a bond of $250 has been filed, pursuant to, Fed.Rules Civ.Proc. rule 73(c), 28 U.S.C.A., as set out in the footnote.1 Costs in the District Court have been taxed by the Clerk at $2,145.30 and no review as to such costs has been taken pursuant to Rule 54(d). The plaintiff, appellee, has filed a motion for an increase of the bond to $2,500 and this is opposed by the defendant, appellant.

The determination of the motion must, in the final analysis, consider the coverage of the bond, i. e., whether the bond covers only the costs incurred in the Court of Appeals or covers as well the costs incurred in the District Court. If the bond should only cover the costs in the Court of Appeals, then the bond of $250 is concededly sufficient. If the effect of the bond on appeal is the coverage *319of the costs in the District Court of $2,-145.30, then the bond of $250 as given is obviously insufficient.

Rule 73 of Federal Rules of Civil Procedure concerning appeals to a Court of Appeals provides for two species of bonds, viz., bonds on appeal (subsection (c) ), and supersedeas bonds (subsection (d) ). The character and coverage of the two classes of bonds differ entirely as to their function and intent. With the latter class (supersedeas bonds), we are not here concerned except incidentally as contrasted with the cost bond on appeal.

Because no case has been found discussing the coverage of a bond on appeal under Rule 73(c) and because such coverage was not entirely uniform under the Statute, prior to the adoption of the Rule, some discussion of the former coverage may not be inappropriate.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.