District Court, D. Minnesota December 24, 1958, Civ. No. 6-57-97 (Donoho v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-12-1958

DONOVAN, District Judge.

Plaintiff brings this suit to recover an allegedly erroneous assessment of income taxes in the total amount of $3,490.44 with interest. Said sum was collected by defendant for the taxable period May 10, 1951, through December 31,1951, and for the year 1952. This case has to do only with the years 1951 and 1952.

Plaintiff is the transferee of the estate of her father, Dr. W. L. Burnap, who, prior to his death on May 9, 1951, was associated with five other medical doctors as partners in the practice of their profession in the city of Fergus Falls, Minnesota, and carried on under the firm name of Fergus Falls Clinic. The Articles of Partnership 1 are in evidence, and will be referred to hereinafter as the Articles. The Articles provided for the continuation of the partnership in the event of death, retirement or disability of any of the partners. There is no dispute about the accuracy of the Articles which, in the foregoing respect, comply with the Statutory Law of Minnesota2, providing that the partnership will not terminate on the death or retirement of a partner thereof, and that the share or interest of the deceased or retiring partner shall pass to and belong to the surviving partners, who in turn shall be obligated to return the value of the share to the retiring partner, or the representative of the estate of the deceased partner.

Paragraph 7 of the Articles provides for the method to be used by the surviving partners in determining the value of the share of the retiring or deceased partner. It reads as follows:

“7. The partnership shall continue at the will of the members, but it shall not ipso facto terminate on the death or the retirement for any reason of any member so long as two or more members remain in the firm.

“Retirement of a member of the firm shall result—

“(a) From his death.

“(b) From total disability existing for a period of six months.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.