Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit February 26, 1959, 25279_1 (Red Star Barge Line, Inc. v. Lizza Asphalt Construction Co., Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-02-1959
264 F.2d 467 RED STAR BARGE LINE, INC., as owner of THE SEABOARD NO. 60, Libelant-Appellee, v. LIZZA ASPHALT CONSTRUCTION CO., Inc., Respondent-Appellant, and New York Trap Rock Corporation, Respondent-Impleaded-Appellee. No. 127. Docket 25279. United States Court of Appeals Second Circuit. Argued January 16, 1959. Decided February 26, 1959. William Warner, New York City (Symmers, Fish, Warner & Nicol, New York City, on the brief), for appellant Lizza. Edward J. Ryan, New York City (Foley & Martin, New York City), for appellee, Red Star Barge Line, Inc. Henry C. Eidenbach, New York City (Hill, Rivkins, Middleton, Louis & Warburton, New York City, on the brief), for appellee, New York Trap Rock Corp. Before MEDINA, LUMBARD and BURGER,* Circuit Judges. BURGER, Circuit Judge. 1 This is an appeal from a judgment for libelant for damages to its Barge No. 60 sustained while tied up and under appellant's control. Four other barges were also moored to the same side of the pier, some following and others awaiting discharge of cargo. Appellant's employees moved Barge No. 60 out from the pier, while it was still fully loaded, to make room at the hopper for another barge to discharge cargo, putting two barges between No. 60 and the pier. As a result the corner of No. 60 farthest from the pier and nearest the shore grounded on a hard ridge. Although no damage was immediately apparent, appellant's employees were aware of the grounding. Subsequently, as the tide fell, No. 60's barge heard the sound of cracking timbers as the barge settled and "hung" on the ridge. This caused the damage which is the subject of the appeal. 2 Appellant's primary theory for reversal is that there was no evidence tending to show knowledge (either actual or constructive), on its part, of the existence of a hard ridge shoal at the point where the grounding occurred. Absent such knowledge, appellant argues, it cannot be found negligent in its handling of the barge.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit