Court of Appeals for the First Circuit July 28, 1959, 5495_1 (Frank H. Kelley, Trustees v. Otto Hansen)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-07-1959

MAGRUDER, Circuit Judge

(Re-

tired) .

This is the second appeal in the above-entitled case. See Kelley v. Hansen, 1 Cir., 1958, 254 F.2d 99.

An amended complaint in two counts was filed by the plaintiffs on May 4, 1955. The first cause of action was predicated upon an alleged oral contract entered into on October 4, 1948, between the plaintiffs and the defendants through their agent, one Sherman H. Bowles, since deceased, who was the publisher and the dominant factor in the Republican Daily News and the Springfield Union. The alleged contract related to complicated transactions involving the shares of stock in Alliance Manufacturing Company, an Ohio corporation; and defendants were alleged to have agreed that, upon any sale of said stock, the plaintiffs were to receh e the sum of $169,000 “together with a reasonable share of the profits made upon such sale.” The second cause of action was like the first, except that the plaintiffs here omitted any allegation that the defendants had promised to pay a reasonable share of the profits, and judgment was demanded only "in said total amount of $169,000 together with interest thereon from September 1, 1954, plus their costs.”

Responding to interrogatories propounded by the court, the jury brought in answers favorable to the plaintiffs as to both counts. As permitted by the trial court’s instructions, the jury reported a single total verdict in the sum of $250,-000, having evidently added $81,000 covering the profits claimed in Count I to the $169,000 claimed in Count II; and the judge thereupon entered judgment for the plaintiffs in the sum of $250,000.

On the first appeal we said: “The second cause of action sought recovery of only the sum of $169,000 with interest. We find no fault with that.” 254 F.2d at page 104. We thought there was error in the recovery of judgment on the first count.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.