Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit November 4, 1959, 6130_1 (Jewell Turner and Cyrus O. Turner v. J. v. Brookshear, Elmer Graham, and Vance Foster)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-11-1959

PHILLIPS, Circuit Judge.

The Turners

1

brought this action against Brookshear, Graham and Foster

2

to reform a mineral deed on the ground of mutual mistake.

On June 14, 1937, plaintiffs executed and delivered to Magnolia Petroleum Company an oil and gas lease of the E i/2 of the NW % of the SW & and the SW y4 of the SW % of S 11, T 2 S, R 5 W, Stephens County, Oklahoma, containing 60 acres. The lease provided it should remain in force for a primary term of 10 years “and as long thereafter as oil, gas, casinghead gas, casinghead gasoline or any of them is or can be produced.” It was duly recorded on July 8, 1937. The lease contained the following provision:

“10. If the leased premises shall hereafter be owned in severalty or in separate tracts, the premises,, nevertheless, shall be developed and operated as one lease and all royalties accruing hereunder shall be treated as an entirety and shall be-divided among and paid to such separate owners in the proportion that the acreage owned by each such separate owner bears to the entire leased acreage. There shall be no-obligation on the part of the lessee-to offset wells on separate tracts into which the land covered by this-lease may be hereafter divided by sale, devise, or otherwise, or to furnish separate measuring or receiving-tanks. * * * If at any time there-be as many as four parties entitled to rentals or royalties, lessee may withhold payments thereof unless- and until all parties designate, in writing, in a recordable instrument to be filed with the lessee, a common agent to receive all payments-due hereunder, and to execute division and transfer orders on behalf of said parties, and their respective successors in title.”

On October 25, 1946, Magnolia executed and delivered to Jack Cohen an assignment of such lease, by which it transferred its interest in the lease, “in so far and only in so far as said lease covers-the Southwest Quarter (SW ¼,) of the Southwest Quarter (SW ¼) of Section.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.