Supreme Court of Oklahoma October 27, 1959, 38573 (In Re Pierce's Appeal)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-10-1959

BLACKBIRD, Justice.

Beginning in 1943, John L. Pierce, who appears herein as defendant in error, but will hereinafter be referred to as applicant, has owned a parcel of real estate in Tulsa, Oklahoma, consisting of a lot with street frontage of SO feet and depth of 85 feet, and a two-story, 4-family, or 4-unit, frame apartment building thereon. He has been living in one of the units, or apartments, and renting to other persons the other three apartments. The property is located in what is designated as a

“U-2

A Zone” district. The uses of property located in such district are described by said City’s Ordinance No. 7937, which was enacted in

1956.

The only multiple family ■ dwellings, or buildings, said ordinance authorizes in such district are those “designed and built to accommodate not more than four family units * * The ordinance further states, among other things: “ * * * pro

*792

vided that no such building shall be erected on a lot or tract of land having less than 50 feet frontage and a minimum lot area of 4,000 square feet per family unit * * ”. Being desirous of constructing an additional building on the above mentioned lot to contain utility and storage space for his tenants in the existing building and to also contain an apartment he could occupy (thus making available for rental to others the one he then occupied) appellant made oral application to Mr. H. W. Goodwin, Tulsa’s Building Inspector, for a building permit to erect a proposed additional building on the lot. Goodwin refused to issue the permit. Later, appellant contacted a building contractor named A. C. Futral, told him of his desire to erect the building; and Futral thereafter obtained for him from one W. R. Thompson, deputy building inspector, a building permit dated October 4,1957, which described the “Nature of Work” (to be performed under it) as a frame addition to the rear of dwelling “2 story — no expansion of living space.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.