Connecticut Superior Court February 6, 1959, File 113083 (Donahue v. New York, New Haven & Hartford Railroad)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-02-1959

FitzGerald, J.

The plaintiff administrator brought this action against the defendant railroad on behalf of the estate of John Henry Meyer, late of the town of Enfield, Connecticut, to recover damages for the death of his decedent at a railroad crossing in Enfield on the afternoon of August 20, 1957. Before the trial was had in October, 1958, the Fillorama Construction Company, Inc., was permitted to intervene as a coplaintiff, under a provision of the Connecticut Workmen’s Compensation Act, as the employer of Mr. Meyer at the time of his death. The trial of the case occupied three court days before a jury of twelve. On the late afternoon of October 16, 1958, the jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff administrator after a deliberation of two and one-half hours, and awarded damages of $46,000. In passing, it may be noted that by agreement of counsel the actual presence in the case of the intervening coplaintiff was not disclosed to the jury.

The defendant has moved to set aside the verdict on the following grounds: (1) contrary to law; (2) against the evidence; (3) excessive. Since the entire charge of the court and exceptions thereto,

*284

which comprise in the over-all forty-six pages of typing, were ordered of the reporter by counsel as well as some of the transcript of evidence, arguments on the within motion were delayed until January 5,1959.

It may be noted that the defendant does not now urge that the death award of $46,000 was excessive. The decedent at the time of his death, which was virtually instantaneous with the collision between the truck he was operating and the defendant’s diesel engine, was twenty-seven years of age and earning $72 a week with a life expectancy actuarially of forty-three years. He was survived by a widow and an infant child. The only item of special damage was the funeral bill, which was about $1000. It may also be noted that the defendant does not particularly urge that the verdict as such is contrary to law.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.