New York Supreme Court January 13, 1959 (Singer v. News Syndicate Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-01-1959
Samuel H. Hofstadter, J.
Plaintiff moves pursuant to subdivision 6 of rule 109 of the Buies of Civil Practice to strike out the defenses for insufficiency. The action is in libel. The publication stated that by an order of this court the defendant had been released from an incarceration which had reached “ the cruel and inhuman stage which public policy condemns ”. Defendant “ did a half a dozen terms averaging three months each as a guest of the sheriff in the jail at 434 W. 37th St. Then, on Oct. 25, 1955, when he was $1,400 in arrears, he was jailed again, and, has been there ever since. His attorney * * * told (the presiding justice) that most of Singer’s previous imprisonments weren’t for contempt of court but rather because fresh arrears were piling up while he was in jail. Almost as soon as he got out, the lawyer said, he would be put back in *549again.” Plaintiff charges that the article and report falsely-charged plaintiff’s imprisonments of her former husband were not for contempts of court but rather for arrears which accrued while he was in jail so that he would be put back in jail almost as soon as he got out and charged plaintiff with violating the law and committing the crime of perjury in securing the orders of commitment for nonpayment of alimony while the defendant was confined to jail.
The first defense pleads the privilege of fair and true report (Civ. Prac. Act, § 337). It sets forth the pertinent facts of the various commitments in chronological order, including an unsuccessful attempt to secure relief with respect to alimony arrears accruing during a period of incarceration, the obtaining of separate orders of commitment based upon failure to comply with separate directions of an order and the decision of the court leading to defendant’s release. Whether the defense places an unfair and unbalanced emphasis upon arrears and upon contempts and whether the publication is capable of generating a charge of perjury are certainly not free from doubt.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit