Summit County Court of Common Pleas March 12, 1959, No. 215574 (Harper v. Lynch)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-03-1959

*497OPINION

By WATTERS, J.

The plaintiff, Harper, was injured personally and his car was damaged as claimed due to the negligence of the defendant, Lynch, operating his or her car here in Summit County.

The defendant is a non-resident of the State and service was had on her or him through the Secretary of State of Ohio under §2703.20 R. C. (old §§6308-1 and 6308-2 GC), in behalf of both plaintiffs.

The plaintiff, Harper, had a collision insurance contract with The New York Underwriters Insurance Company, the other plaintiff, which was a $75.00 deductible policy.

The insurance company paid him $338.90, the plaintiff, Harper, standing the first $75.00 of damage to his car, the insurance company becoming the assignee and subrogee of the $338.90 which it paid Harper.

The insurance company is a party plaintiff as subrogee for said amount paid, while the plaintiff, Harper, sues for $10,000.00 to cover his personal injuries and the first $75.00 damage to his car.

The defendant seeks to have the service quashed, claiming that there is no authority giving to an assignee or subrogee of a property damage claim (or an insurance company, assignee or subrogee) the right to sue a defendant by getting service under §2703.20 R. C. or under the venue statute, §4515.01 R. C., by bringing the action “in the county in which such injury occurred.”

Sec. 4515.01 K. C., is in substance as follows:

“Actions for injury to a person or property, caused by the negligence of the owner or operator of a motor vehicle, may be brought by the person injured against such owner or operator in the county in which such injury occurred-----.”

Defendant claims that the action of such a subrogee or assignee comes under §2307.39 R. C., which provides:

“All actions other than those mentioned-----must be brought in the county in which a defendant resides or may be summoned

But see also §2307.38 R. G.

27 Abs 406, Travelers Insurance Company v. Miller, etc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.