District Court, N.D. Texas August 20, 1959, No. 2598 (Runkle v. Birkmeyer)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-08-1959
BENJAMIN C. DAWKINS, Sr., District Judge.
The circumstances out of which this litigation arose began with an exchange of letters between plaintiff and one H. J. Bice, a real estate dealer residing in Amarillo, Texas. They had known each other for about five years, and from the first letter by Bice to Runkle at his home in Columbus, Ohio, the latter apparently had informed Bice that he owned a tract of land near Harrison, Arkansas, with improvements on it, which was for sale or exchange.1
Attached was a four page “ * * * brief outline of the history of Estate Life Insurance Company of Amarillo, Texas.” Runkle had practiced law for several years, but for some time had been engaged in looking after his business interest, including this Arkansas property known as Western Runmoor Properties, Inc., and on receipt of Bice’s letter, with enclosure, called that gentleman on the telephone. Bice then informed John L. McCarty, President of Estate Life Insurance Company, of Amarillo, that Runkle was interested in the stock of the Estate Life Insurance Company and McCarty, under date of September 17, 1957, wrote Runkle as per plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 3;2 also enclosing several documents, with headings or brief descriptions, including one headed “Appreciation of value versus Immediate Profits”, reciting purported facts and figures showing the phenomenal success of many life insurance companies throughout the United States.
The approximate month between the dates of letters by Bice and McCarty to Runkle was explained by Runkle as due to the fact he was in Europe and the matter did not come to his attention for some weeks. He made no record of dates, but his recollection was that he came to Amarillo about the last week of September or first part of October. Bice escorted Runkle from the hotel in Amarillo to the office of Estate Life Insurance Company, where he met McCarty and others, including J. D. Birkmeyer, now one of the defendants in this suit.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit