District Court, D. Kansas June 17, 1959, Civ. A. No. W-1637 (Shoemake v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-06-1959

RITTER, District Judge.

Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law

This cause having come on for trial on May 28, 1959, before the Court sitting without a jury, and the Court having heard the evidence and the arguments of counsel renders the following Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law:

I

Plaintiffs are citizens of the State of Kansas and residents of the District of *747Kansas. The defendant is a corporate sovereign.

II

During and prior to the years involved in this controversy, 1948 through 1955, various landowners in Butler, Cowley, Greenwood, and other adjoining counties executed oil and gas leases upon their respective tracts of land to various lessees. The leases were executed on the customary “Producers 88” or “Producers 88(b)” type of form. All of the lessees paid valuable consideration for their respective leases.

III

After these lessees had gone upon their leases and drilled wells, they commenced pumping oil from the subsurface oil deposits and sold the marketable crude oil to pipeline companies. A small percentage of the matter brought to the surface by the lessees consisted of oil emulsified with water and other substances, commonly called “tank bottoms” or “tank settlings”. It was impossible to bring marketable crude oil to the surface without also obtaining a percentage of these “tank bottoms”. These tank bottoms had no market value and were commonly spread upon dirt roads.

IV

“Tank bottoms” are concentrated at the bottom of the stock tanks used for gathering and temporary storage of the crude oil, preparatory to its sale to the pipeline companies. If these tank bottoms are not removed from the stock tanks periodically, they will tend to contaminate the crude oil causing the pipeline company to reject any further crude oil from that tank until it has been cleared.

V

Plaintiff, referring to Mr. Shoemake, in the late 1930’s constructed an installation near El Dorado, Kansas, for the purpose of obtaining marketable crude oil from tank bottoms.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.