District Court, S.D. New York June 1, 1959 (Fuhr v. Newfoundland-St. Lawrence Shipping Ltd.)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-06-1959

THOMAS F. MURPHY, District Judge.

This is a claim, tried to the court by agreement of counsel, by an alien seaman against a Panamanian steamship company for overtime and statutory extra wages under Panamanian law. Plaintiff’s second claim for liquidated damages for failure to pay such wages was tried to a jury who returned a verdict for defendant.

Plaintiff, after trial, argues that both claims are properly in this court because they are bottomed on a federal statute, to wit, 46 U.S.C.A. §§ 596, 597, or on an alternate theory that since the jury tried claim was based on a federal statute the court has pendent jurisdiction of the other claim. In his complaint plaintiff claimed to be a citizen of New York and framed his pleading so as to give apparent diversity jurisdiction to his first claim for extra wages, and for his second claim he relied on 46 U.S.C.A. §§ 596, 597. He demanded a jury trial.

Defendant does not contest jurisdiction but we must satisfy ourselves that we have the power to act. We admit to serious doubt on this score but will nevertheless decide the merits with the hope of avoiding another trial in the event we are in error on the question of jurisdiction.

Plaintiff, a citizen of Norway, and not of New York, signed on the M. V. Mercator at New York as chief mate on May 18, 1953, and served in different capacities aboard her until February 18, 1955, when she sailed without him from Bermuda. The M. V. Mercator was registered under the laws of Panama and was owned by defendant, a Panamanian corporation. It flew the Panamanian flag and was engaged in international traffic.

The ship’s articles signed by plaintiff on May 18, 1953, provided for a monthly wage of $270, plus a vacation period at that rate, and for $1 per hour for overtime. While at sea on July 11, 1953, plaintiff and the other members of the crew agreed to eliminate overtime for Sunday and holiday work at sea and each subscribed his name to an agreement to that effect.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.