Supreme Court of Oklahoma December 13, 1960, 38533 (Rush v. Champlin Refining Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-12-1960

WILLIAMS, Vice Chief Justice.

This is the second appeal to this court •arising from the same numbered and styled case in the trial court. See Rush v. Champlin Refining Co. et al., Okl., 321 P.2d 697.

The controversy herein relates to the •meaning and effect of two deeds. These base deeds were executed by A. Plumley in 1925. The pertinent parts of such base deeds were set forth in Rush v. Champlin, etc., supra.

Rush and others, hereinafter referred to as plaintiffs, filed an action to quiet title to the lands covered by the base deeds. Plaintiffs deraigned their interests from Plumley. Defendants deraigned their interests from Plumley’s grantees. Defendants filed demurrers which were sustained, and from adverse judgment the plaintiffs appealed. In Rush v. Champlin Refining Company et al., supra, we reversed the trial court and remanded the case for a new trial.

After a trial to the court sitting without a jury, judgment was entered for the defendants. Plaintiffs appeal.

Plaintiffs’ position is that the base deeds conveyed an undivided ½6⅛ interest in the minerals and the mineral rights and, therefore, defendants were entitled to' ¾sth of ⅛⅛ of the production under an oil and gas lease.

Defendants contend that the base deeds were conveyances of royalty; that they were entitled to ½ of ⅛⅛ 0f the production under an oil and gas lease.

In Rush v. Champlin etc., supra, we said at page 701:

“In each of the deeds here under consideration, there is a substantial element of uncertainty and ambiguity apparent on the face of the instrument. * * * The deeds here involved, however, contain provisions which are completely contradictory and incompatible with other provisions of the same instrument, and in the case of exhibit ‘A’ even the ‘intent clause’ expresses two contradictory and conflicting intentions in the same sentence. Such being the case, the intention of the grantor in these instruments is far from manifest.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.