Supreme Court of Colorado October 10, 1960, 18927 (Crosby v. Watson)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-10-1960

Per Curiam.

The parties appear here as in the trial court and will be so referred to herein.

This review involves a denial by the trial court of plaintiffs’ motion for a preliminary prohibitory injunction with reference to easements claimed by plaintiffs by adverse use through defendant’s lands to their own lands in Douglas County.

*217

Plaintiffs’ lands consist of three parcels aggregating 628 acres, used for pasture of cattle. The main portions of the property are known as the Orion Angus ranch on the west; the easterly part of 160 acres as the Castiles; and Dellwood Springs, a 40-acre tract to the north. The defendants’ property is a 61-acre fishing resort which lies east of the Orion Angus ranch, west of the Castiles and south of Dellwood Springs, and is noncontiguous to the lands of plaintiffs.

It is claimed by the plaintiffs that the easements run over and along a so-called “Bergen trail or old road,” from U. S. Highway 67 easterly through and beyond the Orion Angus ranch to and over defendants’ property; thence easterly to the Castiles; and from the portion of defendants’ premises lying across Trout Creek, running thence in a northerly direction and parallel with the creek to Dellwood Springs.

Following a hearing and a view of the premises, the trial court on October 31, 1958, entered an order containing findings among which were that the plaintiffs failed to make a

prima facie

case in that there was no showing that their predecessors in title, or the public, “made adverse use of easements over defendants’ lands;” and that any use made of such alleged easements was only permissive and not adverse in nature.

Claiming error by the trial court in denying a preliminary injunction enjoining the defendants from preventing plaintiffs having ingress to and egress from defendants’ land to their own lands, the plaintiffs are here seeking a reversal of that order.

The transcript of the evidence is composed of two volumes with exhibits.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.