New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division February 4, 1960 (Lubliner v. Bd. of Alcoholic Bev. Con., Paterson)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-02-1960

59 N.J. Super. 419 (1960) 158 A.2d 54 MORRIS LUBLINER AND CONGREGATION LENATH HAZEDIC, APPELLANTS-APPELLANTS, v. BOARD OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE CONTROL FOR THE CITY OF PATERSON AND AUGUSTUS HUTCHINS, T/A HUTCH'S TAVERN, AND DIVISION OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE CONTROL, DEPARTMENT OF LAW AND PUBLIC SAFETY, STATE OF NEW JERSEY, RESPONDENTS-RESPONDENTS. Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division. Argued November 24, 1959. Decided February 4, 1960. *421 Before Judges PRICE, GAULKIN and SULLIVAN. Mr. Louis Schwartz argued the cause for the appellants-appellants (Schwartz & Schwartz, attorneys). Mr. John E. Selser argued the cause for the respondent-respondent, Augustus Hutchins (Mr. Charles Turndorf, attorney; Mr. Gary O. Turndorf, on the brief). Mr. William J. Rosenberg argued the cause for the respondent-respondent, Board of Alcoholic Beverage Control for the City of Paterson (Mr. Harry Smith, attorney). Mr. Samuel B. Helfand, Deputy Attorney General, argued the cause for the respondent-respondent, Division of Alcoholic Beverage Control (Mr. David D. Furman, Attorney General). The opinion of the court was delivered by GAULKIN, J.A.D. Paterson's three-man Board of Alcoholic Beverage Control granted a place to place transfer to "Hutch's Tavern" by a two to one vote. Upon appeal the Director of the Division of Alcoholic Beverage Control affirmed. Appellants ask us to reverse. Appellants' first point is that "the Director of the Division should have reversed the local A.B.C. Board on the principle *422 of res judicata." The discussion of that point will provide the factual background necessary for the disposition of the remaining grounds urged for reversal. Hutch's Tavern has been located in rented premises at 34 Straight Street, Paterson since prior to 1947. The licensee, Augustus Hutchins, purchased a building at 39 Carroll Street, Paterson and in 1947 applied for a place to place transfer of the tavern to that address.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.