Superior Court of Pennsylvania November 16, 1960, Appeal, 295 (Commonwealth Ex Rel. Sliva v. Banmiller)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-11-1960
Opinion by
Watkins, J.,
This is an appeal from the dismissal of a petition for a writ of habeas corpus by the Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County. The record discloses that eight bills of indictment were found against the defendant-appellant, Henry Sliva. Four of the bills contained two counts each of robbery and robbery while armed with an offensive weapon. Three bills have one count of burglary and a count of violation of the Uniform Firearms Act. The defendant was found guilty of all counts in all the bills except the bill charging violation of the Uniform Firearms Act.
The appellant raised two questions by this appeal (ll) may a person accused of a felony be tried with less than twelve jurors? and (2) may not an indictment be properly regarded as null and void when it is found to contain three separate charges which arise out of three separate transactions?
“A constitutional right of a defendant on trial for crime other than murder may be waived on his behalf by his counsel. There is a presumption that counsel
*497
at the trial in this case acted on authority from the defendant and that presumption is strengthened by the fact of defendant’s presence in court when the right was waived, and especially by his acquiescence during the remainder of the trial in proceeding with eleven jurors.”
Commonwealth v. Adams,
187 Pa. Superior Ct. 611, 614, 145 A. 2d 729 (1958). See also:
Com. ex rel. Paylor v. Cavell,
185 Pa. Superior Ct. 176, 138 A. 2d 246 (1958). In the instant case the record shows that when a juror reported sick on the second day of the trial, the trial continued with only-eleven jurors after the court below secured the individual waivers of the district attorney, counsel for the defendant and the defendant himself.
As to the second question, we agree with the disposition made by the court below in holding, “The Superior Court in Commonwealth ex rel. Burge v. Ashe, 168 Pa. Superior Ct.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit