California Court of Appeal October 28, 1960, Crim. No. 7030 (People v. Palmer)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-10-1960
VALLÉE, J.
A jury found defendant guilty of murder of the second degree. He appeals from the judgment.
Defendant and Robert Gibbons, the deceased, lived together in apartment 4 at 1102 Dawson Street in Long Beach and represented themselves as brothers. The apartment was in a court. During the afternoon of July 1, 1959, defendant was seen entering and leaving the apartment several times. June Clem saw him walking into the court sometime before 5 p. m. About 5:30 p. m. the manager received the rent for apartment 4 from the deceased. A short time thereafter she and June Clem heard a thud.
A few minutes before 6 p. m. Fred Goode saw defendant come in with the deceased. Defendant had the deceased “by the shirt of the right shoulder and was kind of pushing and leading him toward the court.” The deceased “had kind of a staring, shocked look on his face, kind of a blank stare, wide-eyed stare. He had his right hand across his stomach. They turned into the court.”
Jean Reynolds also saw defendant and the deceased. She said they were side by side; defendant held the deceased by the shoulder. The deceased had his hand over his abdomen; he “looked like he might have been—well, he sort of pinched his face. It was kind of pinched up a little bit like he had a pain. James [defendant] looked rather angry or disturbed about something. ’'
About 15 minutes later defendant walked out of the court to the sidewalk and went toward Goode, stopped, muttered something, shook his head, rubbed his hand through his hair, walked around the building and entered apartment 4 from the rear. Some time later Goode saw Carl Graves standing in front of apartment 4 grasping the screen door. Goode saw someone inside the apartment.
About 7 p. m. Jean Reynolds saw defendant and another person enter the deceased’s car “to proceed towards downtown. ’ ’ She thought the other person might have been Graves. Defendant drove away “in a very reckless, hurried manner.” The brakes “squealed real loud.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit